Canada and the Beginning of the Cold War: Modern Interpretations

DOI: 10.17721/2521-1706.2019.08.05

Maryna Bessonova

PhD in History, Associate Professor, State Institution «Institute of World History of NAS of Ukraine», Kyiv, Ukraine

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1533-775X

Abstract

The most widespread plots interpreted as the beginning of the Cold War are the events that took place in 1946: February 9 – J. Stalin’s speech to the electorate in Moscow; February 22 – the American charge d’Affaires in the Soviet Union G. Kennan’s “long telegram”; March 5 – W. Churchill’s speech in Fulton (the USA); September 27 – the Soviet Ambassador in the United States N. Novikov’s “long telegram”. But there was an earlier event, so called “Gouzenko affair”, which is almost unknown for the Ukrainian historiography. On September 5, 1945, Igor Gouzenko, a cipher clerk of the Soviet embassy to Canada, defected to the Canadian side with more than a hundred secret documents that proved the USSR’s espionage activities in the countries of North America. Information about the network of Soviet agents caused a real panic in the West and was perceived as a real start of the Cold War.

In the article, there is made an attempt to review the main events related to the Gouzenko affair and to identify the dominant interpretations of this case in contemporary historical writings. One can find different interpretations of the reasons and the consequences of Gouzenko’s defection which dramatically affected the history of the world. One of the main vivid results was an anti-communist hysteria in the West which was caused by the investigation that Canadian, American and British public officials and eminent scientists were recruited by the Soviet Union as agents for the atomic espionage. For Canada, the Gouzenko affair had an unprecedented affect because on the one hand it led to the closer relations with the United States in the sphere of security and defense, and on the other hand Canada was involved into the international scandal and used this case as a moment to start more activities on the international arena.

It has been also found that the Canadian and American studies about Gouzenko affair are focused on the fact that the Allies on the anti-Hitler coalition need to take a fresh look at security and further cooperation with the USSR, while the overwhelming majority of Russian publications is focused on the very fact of betrayal of Igor Gouzenko.

Key words: Canada, Cold War, Gouzenko affair, espionage.

Full text

References:

  1. Ageeva, I. (2003). Kanada i nachalo kholodnoj vojny: delo Guzenko v sovetsko-kanadskikh otnosheniyakh. Kholodnaya vojna 1945-1963 gg. Istoricheskaya retrospektiva, Moskva: OLMA-PRESS, 369- [In Russian].
  2. Bessonova, M. (2009). «Dovhi telehramy» ta pochatok Kholodnoyi viyny. Istorychna nauka na pochatku ХХІ stolittya: problemy, mynule, suchasnistʹ, perspektyvy, Kherson: Khersonsʹkyy derzhavnyy universytet, 119-120. [In Ukrainian].
  3. Honchar, Yu. (2016). Borotʹba proty pidryvnoyi ta shpyhunsʹkoyi diyalʹnosti: dosvid SSHA u roky Pershoyi svitovoyi viyny Amerykansʹka istoriya ta polityka, 1, 175-183, http://www.americanstudies.history.knu.ua/en/struggle-against-subversion-and-espionage-the-united-states-during-the-first-world-war-experience/ [In Ukrainian].
  4. Dragunskiy, D. (2018). Tsinichnoye bezobraziye SSSR: razoblacheniye po-predatel’ski. Obozrevatel’, https://www.obozrevatel.com/society/tsinichnoe-bezobrazie-sssr-razoblachenie-po-predatelski.htm [In Russian].
  5. Dyurozel’, Zh.-B. (1995). Istoriya dyplomatiyi vid 1919 roku do nashykh dniv. Kyiv: Osnovy. [In Ukrainian].
  6. Braun, K. (Ed.) (2019). Ilyustrovana istoriya Kanady, Lʹviv: Litopys. [In Ukrainian].
  7. Kiian, S. (2018, September 24). Krostnyy otets kholodnoy voyny. Perebezhchik Guzenko sdal 1700 sovetskikh agentov. Nasha versiia, 37, https://versia.ru/perebezhchik-guzenko-sdal-1700-sovetskix-agentov [In Russian].
  8. Mal’kov, V.L. (1990). Pervyye pis’ma s «kholodnoy voyny»: «Dlinnaya telegramma» Kennana i analiticheskiy obzor Novikova «Vneshnyaya politika SSHA v poslevoyennyy period». Mezhdunarodnaya zhizn’, 11, 138-154. [In Russian].
  9. Mlechin, L. (2006). Predsedateli organov gosbezopasnosti. Rassekrechennyye sud’by. Moskva: Tsentrpoligraf. [In Russian].
  10. Mlechin, L. (2011). Kholodnaya voyna. Politiki, polkovodtsy, razvedchiki. Moskva: Tsentrpoligraf. [In Russian].
  11. Baran, Z., Kyparenko, H., Kozytsʹkyy, L., Movchan, S., Siromsʹkyy, R., Shvahurlyak, M. (Eds.). (2011). Novitnya istoriya krayin Zakhidnoyi Yevropy ta Pivnichnoyi Ameryky (1945 r. – pochatok XXI). L’viv: Triada plyus. [In Ukrainian].
  12. Poklyats’ka, V. (2014). Protystoyannya SRSR ta SSHA u 1946–1979 rr.: zasoby formuvannya «obrazu voroha». Naukovi zapysky Ternopilʹsʹkoho natsionalʹnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni Volodymyra Hnatyuka. Seriya: Istoriya. Ternopil’, 2(1), 158-164. [In Ukrainian].
  13. Rasskazov, A.V. (2004). Interv’yu I. Guzenko 1954 i sovetsko-amerikanskiye otnosheniya. Vestnik Nizhegorodskogo universiteta im. N.I. Lobachevskogo. Seriya: Mezhdunarodnyye otnosheniya. Politologiya. Regionovedeniye, 1, 33-39. [In Russian].
  14. Trofimenkov, M. (2013, September 9). Podvig predatelya. Kommersant”. Vlast’, 35, https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2259561 [In Russian].
  15. Tumashov, A. (2000). «Kholodna viyna» i yiyi nehatyvnyy vplyv na mizhnarodnu atmosferu v 60-80 rr. XXI Visnyk Natsionalʹnoho universytetu «Lʹvivsʹka politekhnika», 408, 116-122. [In Ukrainian].
  16. Chertoprud, S. (2002). Nauchno-tekhnicheskaya razvedka ot Lenina do Gorbacheva. Moskva: OLMA-PRESS. [In Russian].
  17. Shvarev, N. (2017, November 3). Nevozvrashchenets Igor’ Guzenko. Osobennosti okhoty sovetskoy razvedki za atomnymi sekretami v Kanade. Nezavisimoye voyennoye obozreniye, http://nvo.ng.ru/spforces/2017-11-03/6_972_canada.html[In Russian].
  18. Shcherbina, T. (n.d.) Vliyaniye «dela Guzenko» na oslozhneniye kanado-sovetskikh otnosheniy v period kholodnoy voyny. Informatsionnyye materialy dlya studentov, https://superinf.ru/view_helpstud.php?id=2912 [In Russian].
  19. Bessonova, M. (2010). Soviet Perspective on the Сold War and American Foreign Policy. Comparative Perspectives on the Cold War: National and Sub-National Approaches. Krakow: Krakowska Akademia, 41-58. [In English].
  20. Bessonova, M. (2019). The Cold War in Post-Soviet Interpretations: the case of Ukrainian and Belorussian school history textbooks. Ideology and politics, 2(13), 198-213, https://ideopol.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/____ENG.%201.11.%20Bessonova%20%20FIN.pdf [In English].
  21. Clément, D. (2000). Spies, Lies, and a Commission: A Case Study in the Mobilization of the Canadian Civil Liberties Movement. Left History, 7(2), 53-79. [In English].
  22. Igor Gouzenko – Historic (n.d.). Andrew Kravchak Youtube channel, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=twr5ubpYArQ&list=UUKKfXpfGOtrMs87tLOwlsHQ&index=68 [In English].
  23. Kavchak, A. (2019). Remembering Gouzenko: The Struggle to Honour a Cold War Hero. Independently published. [In English].
  24. Knight, A. (2006). How the Cold War Began: The Igor Gouzenko Affair and the Hunt for Soviet Spies. New York: Avalon Publishing group. [In English].
  25. Knight, A. (2002). The Gouzenko Affair Revisited: The Soviet Perspective. Canadian Intelligence Resource Centre Archives, http://circ.jmellon.com/docs/view.asp?id=165 [In English].
  26. Molinaro, D. (2017). How the Cold War Began … with British Help: The Gouzenko Affair Revisited. Labour/Le Travail, 79, 143-155. [In English].
  27. Schulzinger, (1994). American Diplomacy in the twentieth century. N.Y.-Oxford: Oxford University Press. [In English].
  28. (n.d.). Soviet Spy Scandal. News of a widespread spy ring in Canada cools relations with the Soviet Union. ca, https://www.cbc.ca/history/EPISCONTENTSE1EP15CH1PA1LE.html [In English].